Minwax Vs Varathane Oil Finish

Do not puncture, incinerate, burn or store above 120°F. Briana is a plant and ecology enthusiast who is happiest when she’s working on a project. She has spent over ten years learning about and working with sustainable agriculture, both on research plots, in educational labs, and on commercial farms. She currently spends time growing vegetables in her market garden. The table I made ended up with 6 coats and dried for 1 week. I put it in the back of my pickup and drove 350 miles from my house in California to my sons house in Arizona.

The properties and usage of both types of poly shades are different. Water-based minwax polyshade is durable and best for coatings. Varathane products tend to be more expensive than the Minwax products. For instance, Varathane wood stain ranges between $10.30- $16.30, while a can of Minwax costs $7.98. Varathane products use very little time to dry as compared to the Minwax products which take longer. On the other hand, Minwax products require one to apply several layers of coating to get the color required.

Varathane Wood Finish Products

I feel this is an important area to understand if consumers are to be pleased and contractors are to establish a good reputation. Each finish adds to the final color(except water based which generally dries clear. This process is so critical because of what happens when you apply a finish—which is that the wood’s natural grain and beauty is enhanced. However, finishes also amplify defects, making it vital to address imperfections beforehand. Additionally, if the wood is not properly prepared, you may encounter difficulties getting the color to absorb. In this case, choose a Varathane product over Minwax, which will prevent water from entering your wood surfaces.

That usually causes the person doing the work to be upset/confused/mad and they blame the products instead of the missing information necessary to get the desired results. I use it quite a bit on the tops of my furniture that I restore and there are a couple of things why I love this product a lot. Anti-corporation sarcasm aside, seriously, its just the illusion of choice being monetized. If you want a better example, look at power tools, specifically 14 inch bandsaws.

Should You Apply Sand Between Coats?

Of the three water based finishes I mentioned these are products that some clients prefer by name. What can be agreed upon by any maker of professional products is that they all in fact are superior to what’s generally a household name to homeowners. Additionally as you know regardless of what finish is used, the finish is only going to be as good as the sanding and preparation prior to the application of finish.

minwax vs varathane polyurethane

Oil based polyurethane, on the other hand, is prone to “sheeting,” scratching or chipping after the first couple layers. This mid-range product is exceptional for outdoor applications. It dries fast, allowing a second coat in only two hours. It should not be used on pre-stained or painted surfaces, as it has a tendency to yellow, but works wonders on natural wood surfaces.

If you’re sensitive to smells, you’ll appreciate this water-based polyurethane’s mild to non-existent odor. You can install it using a variety of application techniques. Most consumers said were in agreement that Bona HD holds up well over time.

minwax vs varathane polyurethane

It can be used to cover up to 50 square feet, making it great value and versatile. This polyurethane provides tough abrasion-resistant protection to your wood flooring and furniture, which can add value to your home. It will keep all wood looking high quality for years to come and the formula will remain clear. As it is designed for interior use, this polyurethane is low odor and has a relatively quick drying time. This polyurethane dries fast once it has been applied and will offer lasting beauty on a range of different wood types. It has a durable finish that can enhance the natural beauty of the wood.

Bona Mega Wood Floor Finish

Besides, protecting the natural beauty of the wood surface, it adds on to the beauty of the wood. The raw materials used to make water based polyurethane cost more than that of oil based polyurethane, so the final price you pay is typically higher, too. ​If you’ve ever embarked on a woodworking project, you know that wood can easily become dry and brittle if not protected from the elements. To prevent this, you should always coat wood furniture, deck boards, cabinets, and other projects with some sort of a clear finish. Even if you are looking for a more natural look and decide not to stain the materials, polyurethane can help protect the look and functionality of wood for years to come. This polyurethane is made for interior use and it can be applied to a variety of different wooden furnishings and surfaces around the home.

In general, though, you can expect to wait 24 hours or more before the coating is fully cured. Contrary to the perception of many people, water-based polyurethanes are super durable too and at times more durable than the oil-based ones. This is due to the fact that producers and research centers keep on testing and improving the formula of making these finishes and particularly water-based.

Because the polyurethane finish represents the main barrier between your floors and the outside world, you can expect that they will take some damage over time. As such, you will need to touch-up or replace the finish once in a while. You will only need to do this job once every 7-10 years, and you may not even need to do it that often. Right now, you might be groaning at the prospect of not being able to walk on your floors for the next 24 hours.

minwax vs varathane polyurethane

The two most popular options, polyurethane and varnish, offer different levels of durability and appeal despite being grouped together. Another glossy polyurethane varnish, this option has a crystal-clear finish that does well for light-colored woods like maple, ash, and birch. The fast-drying formula allows quick recoats in just two hours, and the low-odor composition prevents headaches while you work.

It is low-odor and glides on to surfaces easily, with little to no bubbling. It has a short cure time and sometimes doesn’t even require more than a couple of coats. ITs quick application and dry times make it an ideal finish for novice carpenters, woodworkers, or DIYers.


The published instruction from one author who suggests doing this is to brush one foot every eight seconds and not brush back over. If you shake a finish vigorously, as I did this jar containing polyurethane , thousands of tiny bubbles appear. So it’s more important to know how to deal with the inevitable bubbles than to follow instructions not to shake. Not only does polyurethane not need thinning or a special product to create a better bond to the wood, but it also sands easily on its own without clogging sandpaper. So authors and manufacturers have much more opportunity to provide inaccurate information, intentionally or not, about finishes than about woodworking tools and procedures.

Texture Of Finishing

Arthur B. Harrison initially founded the company in 1904. The first Minwax products kept the moisture out of buildings and homes. It is an environment-friendly company that even provides wood finishing products to Rolls Royce.

Humidity can also sometimes cause some clear finishes to blush, or take on a whitish, cloudy haze after they are applied to the wood. This is caused by moisture getting trapped under the finish. Often, once the humid weather stops, the blush will go away as the moisture evaporates.

  • To and insult to injury you will not be able to tell until you apply a new top coat.
  • It leaves no yellowish color on the wood surface and dries relatively faster than the oil-based counterpart.
  • I like to read about other people’s experiences with various projects.
  • With this polyurethane, you can easily protect your wood furnishings and décor as it is an aerosol.
  • This polyurethane is made to be low odor so it can be used indoors on furniture, railings, and trim.
  • To achieve the desired color shade, two coats of the polyshades are required.
  • Both Minwax and Varathane are excellent choices for staining and preparation.
  • This quality makes the Varathane products more effective and time saving.
  • It protects the wood spills, oils , dirt and variety of other things.
  • The Varathane Premium oil-based Floor Finish is painstakingly formulated to provide optimum protection for hardwood floors.

I have beginner classes all the way up expert trade classes. How long do you want this polyurethane to last, both after its initial application and before it is even used? If this doesn’t work, you can often repair the white rings by buffing the damaged area of the surface with a mild abrasive. For example, use a soft, dampened cloth and baking soda mixed with non-gel toothpaste to buff. Finishes that offer protection for wood with a soft luster. Vapors will accumulate readily and may ignite explosively.

I am using the minwax poly on my “practice” piece, the top of an old dresser. I have done quite a few coats, sanding with 0000 steel wool in between coats. I thought I was done, but lint settled in the “final ” coat overnight. These dressers came from the side of the road and were moved twice. mdln,may I ask questions that might help me better understand inquiries of this type? Odds are “your pro” also has products and methods he’s comfortable with.

Handyman: All wood finishes are not created equal – The Detroit News

Handyman: All wood finishes are not created equal.

Posted: Thu, 07 May 2015 07:00:00 GMT [source]

The five-hour wait between coats and 12-hour wait after the last coat will put a bedroom out of commission for a few days. These convenient wipes are good for small projects, are easy to use, and come in several popular shades. Affordability is one of the greatest advantages of polyurethanes. It is such that the major reason they are getting really popular is that with the many advantages they have, one should expect to have some ‘deep pockets’ to afford them.

The choice on which to use depends on what you intend to achieve in your surfaces. The water-based formula is ideal if you wish to maintain the natural beauty and grain of the wood because they generally give clear finishes to the wooden surfaces. The oil-based formula, on the other hand, may alter the natural look of wood by making it appear a little darker but yet offers minwax vs varathane polyurethane better durability and is ideal for external use. Water-based formula has less odor and is ideal for interior use. In the end, the choice on which to use depends on what you wish to achieve in your hardwood floor. This Minwax Fast-Drying Polyurethane is easy to use and makes wood easy to be cared for as it offers maximum protection against an array of potential damages.

It’s also a suitable finish choice for light woods, such as maple and hickory. Despite my lack of formal training, I found it easy to apply my chosen finish. Now, my floors look nearly as shiny and new as the day when I moved in.

The downside to oil-based polyurethane is that you have to put up with strong odors as you’re working, and the drying times are long. But for lots of people, this tradeoff is well worth the bright, intense color results they get from oil-based finishes. Many DIYers and professionals alike consider oil-based polyurethane to be the clear winner. Oil-based polyurethane is more cost effective, provides longer-lasting finishing, and looks better.

Of course, a vital component of dry time is how many coats you need to get the right finish. As we mentioned, Minwax also requires several coats, which, combined with extended drying time, can significantly slow down your whole project. While one of the principal reasons for treating wood is to make it look beautiful, another important reason is to add protection. You want your project to look nice for a long time and stay in good shape. A quality product should provide long-term protection against dents, scratches, humidity, high temperatures, and spills.

Source: homemakerguide.com

اترك تعليقاً

لن يتم نشر عنوان بريدك الإلكتروني.